"Well...no. We could only recruit one other member to our team, actually. But we did try very hard." Even Haru, who specifically tried to use his little bird keychains as a bribe.

"In fact, I'm not entirely sure what happened to all of the extra ones." Rei and Nagisa probably have them now, since it's their job to get more members to replace him and Haru. Which...he's been trying not to think too hard about, even if it is true.